24/04/2012 - Is nursing a vocation or a career?

#NurChat to discuss "Is nursing a vocation or a career?" Tues 24th April 8pm

Nurses have had a lot of criticism of late for not being caring enough, only earlier this month The Independent ran a series of reports about “the crisis in nursing”, the Prime Minister wants to release “time to care” and reports such as the Mid Staffordshire Inquiry and the Patients Association Report all point to a lack of good fundamental care in nursing. But when we look at modern nursing what do we see? Are modern nurses trained to be managers? Nursing used to be a calling, a vocation –do modern nurses have this calling and do we need it? Are nurses fundamentally caring these days or are we just climbing the career ladder on our way to be managers?  Do nurses come into nursing for the right reasons?

Please click on the picture to download a prinatble / emailable flyerto share with other nurses

Below are some links to background reading that you may find useful -please feel fee to add you own links via the comments section.

Christina Patterson:  More nurses, better paid than ever- so why are standards going down? - The Independant

Nursing is no longer the caring profession - The Telegraph

New forum must focus on the future and not look backwards  - Nursing Times

It's not just a career, its a calling - Nurse Together

Reawaken your sense of vocationby remebering nursing history - NursingTimes

Summary by Teresa Chinn RN

______________________________________________________________

Post Chat Summary 



The subject of this NurChat was - Is nursing a calling? The chat started by asking exactly that and NurChatters initial thoughts: Many felt that it was a calling for them and some felt very strongly that it is both a calling and a career. Some distinction was made between days gone by when nursing was seen as a calling and modern day nursing careers starting with a university based education. A point was made that perhaps a sense of vocation helps us to be great nurses.

It was then asked if participants felt that a nurse was something we are as well as something we do – a noun and a verb? Most participants wholeheartedly agreed that it was.

It was also raised if nursing was a personality trait? Some participants felt that their person centred personalities helped with nursing

It was mentioned that if nursing was a calling is that the reason for low pay and would we do it for nothing? Some thought that low wages attracted people who wanted to nurse for the right reasons, others tweeted that they would nurse as volunteers as they loved it, and one participant tweeted do you have to do something for free for it to be a calling? It was further discussed if our calling may be the reason for our poor pay – in that we would happily do it for nothing and this gives employers a point to exploit, some agreed with this and felt that there were always those who will take advantage.

The role of good mentors in nursing and how this shapes our ability to be good nurses was also addressed; it was asked if NurChatters could remember a nurse they wanted to be like? Most could but it was added that there were also those mentors that they did not want to be like. Some disagreed that mentors did not help make good nurses but show the way and bring out the best in us. It was also tweeted that leaders are important and that they should set direction and inspire others and that caring is infectious.

NurChat asked if anyone was from a long line of nurses and if nursing was in our soul? many participants reported that they were from a long line of nurses and some felt very passionately that nursing is inbuilt in them.  Many NurChatters reported that they wanted to be nurses from young ages.

The X factor in nursing was discussed and it was put forward that good communication is vital – most agreed that this was a fundamental part of nursing.  

To conclude the chat NurChat tweeted “so we all came into nursing for different reasons be it a calling or a career – why do we stay?” Participants had a variety of answers ranging from it is in their heart and soul, some stated that they would die happy and enriched, some believed that they were making a difference, some liked to talk and some liked to see smiles.  Most agreed with @Ramck001 when he tweeted “If heaven exists nursing is probably a free pass for most of us”

This link was shared during this chat 

 This article by Jenni (nursing times net) struck a chord with me today - adds value to tonight's #nurchathttp://t.co/I3PPTPnz

Summary by Teresa Chinn RN


______________________________________________________________
Chat transcript (via Storify)

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Nursing is a calling! I've waited a long time to train first marrying, then bringing up a family. I'm now second year student nurse and loving every minute. I feel so proud to be training and still pinch myself every time I put on my uniform.
Once qualified, I don't see myself as a manager in the future, therefore some may call me unambitious. All I want to do is nurse. Bring back bedside nursing.